Biofinity Toric XR vs Proclear Multifocal XR: Which to Pick?
By Lensabl | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Comparisons
Compare Biofinity Toric XR and Proclear Multifocal XR monthly specialty lenses. See how their materials and designs differ, and which eye condition each is built for.
Quick answer
Choose Biofinity Toric XR if you have high astigmatism and need a toric lens; choose Proclear Multifocal XR if you have presbyopia and want a monthly multifocal. They solve different vision problems, so your prescription—not the price—decides.
The core difference: toric vs. multifocal design
These are not interchangeable lenses. Biofinity Toric XR is a toric lens for astigmatism, while Proclear Multifocal XR is a multifocal lens for presbyopia. A toric design corrects the uneven curve of the cornea; a multifocal design adds zones for near, intermediate, and distance vision. If you have both high astigmatism and presbyopia, neither lens alone covers both—you would need a prescription that combines those corrections, which these two products do not claim to do.
Material and handling differences
Biofinity Toric XR uses 52% comfilcon A, a silicone hydrogel known for high oxygen permeability. Proclear Multifocal XR uses 41% omafilcon A, a hydrogel that CooperVision markets for its ability to retain moisture. In practice, the higher water content of omafilcon A may feel more comfortable at insertion for some wearers, while the silicone hydrogel in Biofinity may better support long wearing days. Neither material is universally better—your tear film and wearing schedule matter more than the percentage alone.
What the XR label means—and what it doesn't
XR stands for extended range. For Biofinity Toric XR, that means the lens covers higher cylinder powers than the standard Biofinity Toric, making it an option for high astigmatism contacts. For Proclear Multifocal XR, XR indicates a wider range of add powers for presbyopia. However, the catalog does not list the exact parameter ranges for either lens. Your eye care professional must confirm whether your prescription falls within the available powers; do not assume XR covers every prescription.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Vision condition match: Biofinity Toric XR corrects astigmatism; Proclear Multifocal XR corrects presbyopia. If you have high astigmatism, the toric lens is the only one of the two that addresses your refractive error. If you have presbyopia without significant astigmatism, the multifocal lens is the relevant option. Check your prescription for cylinder (astigmatism) and add power (presbyopia) before comparing anything else.
- Material and comfort: Biofinity Toric XR uses 52% comfilcon A (silicone hydrogel), which may suit wearers who want high oxygen transmission for long days. Proclear Multifocal XR uses 41% omafilcon A, a hydrogel that may appeal to those who prioritize initial moisture and softness. There is no single winner—trial wearing is the only way to know which feels better on your eyes. If you have dry eye tendencies, ask your eye care professional which material is more appropriate for your tear film.
- Parameter availability: Both are XR (extended range) lenses, but the catalog does not specify the exact power ranges. Biofinity Toric XR extends cylinder options for high astigmatism; Proclear Multifocal XR extends add powers for presbyopia. Your prescription must fall within the available parameters, which only your eye care professional can confirm. Do not order based on the XR label alone—verify your exact parameters with your eye care professional first.
Product facts at a glance
- Biofinity Toric XR - 6 Pack: Biofinity Toric XR is a monthly disposable soft contact lens for astigmatism, made of 52% comfilcon A by CooperVision. This lens is designed specifically to correct astigmatism, so it is the relevant choice only if your prescription includes a cylinder correction.
Biofinity Toric XR - 6 Pack - Proclear Multifocal XR - 6 pack: Proclear Multifocal XR is a monthly replacement soft contact lens made of 41% omafilcon A by CooperVision. Its multifocal design addresses presbyopia, so it is appropriate only if you need help with near vision and your prescription includes an add power.
Proclear Multifocal XR - 6 pack
Who should choose which
Best for
- People with high astigmatism who need a toric lens in extended cylinder powers
- Wearers who prefer a silicone hydrogel material with high oxygen permeability for monthly replacement
Not for
- Anyone who needs a multifocal correction for presbyopia
- People with astigmatism whose prescription falls outside the available toric parameters
