Two monthly toric lenses, two different material stories
If you have astigmatism and wear monthly lenses, Bausch + Lomb Ultra for Astigmatism and CooperVision Proclear Toric are both 6-packs of monthly disposable soft toric lenses. The meaningful differences start with what each lens is made of and how the manufacturer describes its comfort design. This comparison sticks to the supplied product records so you can see what is confirmed, what is not, and which questions to bring to your eye doctor.
Neither record includes fitting guidance, replacement schedules beyond 'monthly,' or care instructions. Those details depend on your prescription and your eye care professional's direction, not on a product page.
Material and design: what each record confirms
- Ultra For Astigmatism - 6 Pack: Material: 54% samfilcon A; Manufacturer: Bausch & Lomb; Lens type: monthly disposable soft contact lenses; 6 lenses per box in buffered saline solution. A higher water content is not automatically better or worse, but it is a concrete difference from Proclear Toric's 38% omafilcon B. If you have been curious about a silicone-hydrogel-style material name, samfilcon A is the one to research further with your eye doctor.

Ultra For Astigmatism - 6 Pack - Ultra For Astigmatism - 6 Pack: The product description names MoistureSeal technology and OpticAlign Design, and says the lens was designed with sustained digital device usage in mind. These are manufacturer design claims, not independent test results. They tell you what Bausch + Lomb emphasizes—stable vision and comfort during screen-heavy days—so you can judge whether that matches your own routine.
- Proclear Toric - 6 Pack: Material: 38% omafilcon B; Manufacturer: CooperVision; Lens type: monthly replacement disposable soft contact lenses; 6 daily wear tinted soft contact lenses in buffered 0.9% saline. The lower water content and the 'daily wear tinted' description are the record's clearest distinctions. Tinted lenses can be easier to spot in the case, but the record does not say the tint changes vision or comfort.

Proclear Toric - 6 Pack - Proclear Toric - 6 Pack: The product description cites PC Technology, which creates a material containing phosphorylcholine (PC), a substance found naturally in human cell membranes, and says these molecules attract and surround themselves with water. This is CooperVision's explanation for the lens's moisture retention claim. It is useful context for comparing comfort philosophies, but it is not a guarantee of how the lens will feel on your eye.
Side-by-side on the facts that matter for a 6-pack decision
Both lenses are sold as 6-packs and both records list an annual supply of 4 boxes. The table below summarizes only supplied evidence; where a detail is absent, treat it as unknown rather than as a product flaw.
- Material and water content: Ultra for Astigmatism: 54% samfilcon A. Proclear Toric: 38% omafilcon B. Neither record states oxygen permeability or modulus, so you cannot compare those from this page alone.
- Pack size and annual supply: Both are 6 lenses per box, with 4 boxes listed as an annual supply. That is 24 lenses per year if you follow a monthly replacement rhythm, but the records do not spell out a replacement schedule—confirm it with your eye doctor.
- Design claims: Ultra names MoistureSeal and OpticAlign Design and mentions digital device usage. Proclear Toric names PC Technology and phosphorylcholine. These are manufacturer descriptions, not head-to-head clinical results.
- Tint: Proclear Toric is described as tinted; the Ultra record does not mention a tint. If handling visibility matters to you, that is a practical difference to note, though tint is cosmetic and does not affect prescription.
- Extended range and multifocal options: The Proclear Toric record mentions Proclear Toric XR for extended power ranges and Multifocal Toric for astigmatism with presbyopia. The Ultra record mentions regular spherical, multifocal for presbyopia, and multifocal for astigmatism variants. Availability of those variants in this store is not confirmed by the supplied records.
How to use this comparison without overreading it
A material percentage and a technology name are starting points, not a verdict. The Ultra for Astigmatism 6 Pack record emphasizes a higher water content and a design aimed at screen-heavy days. The Proclear Toric 6 Pack record emphasizes a lower water content and a moisture-attracting material. Neither record includes measured comfort scores, handling characteristics, or fit data, so you cannot rank them objectively from this information alone.
The most useful next step is to compare these facts with what you already know about your eyes. If you have worn a silicone hydrogel lens before and liked it, the samfilcon A material may be worth discussing. If you have preferred lower-water-content lenses or want a tinted lens for easier handling, Proclear Toric gives you a concrete reason to ask about it. Your eye doctor can tell you whether either lens is available in your prescription and whether the material suits your tear film and wearing schedule.
Questions that will settle the choice faster than a spec sheet
Bring these to your eye care professional; the supplied records do not answer them.
- Is my prescription available in both lenses?: The records list standard variants but do not show a full power range. Toric lenses require specific cylinder and axis values, so availability can differ by prescription.
- Does my wearing schedule match a monthly replacement lens?: Both are monthly disposable lenses, but the records do not state daily wear limits or replacement timing. Your eye doctor sets those based on your eyes and habits.
- Do I want a tinted lens?: Proclear Toric is described as tinted; the Ultra record does not mention tint. This is a handling preference, not a vision correction difference.
- Have I had comfort issues with high-water or low-water materials before?: The 54% vs 38% water content difference is real, but the records do not predict how either lens will feel on your eyes. Your history is more useful than a percentage.
Catalog pricing context for the 6-packs
- Ultra For Astigmatism - 6 Pack: Catalog price: USD 53.95; catalog comparison price: USD 75.99. This is the listed price at the time of writing, not a permanent value. Use it as a budget reference when comparing the two 6-packs.
- Proclear Toric - 6 Pack: Catalog price: USD 88.95; catalog comparison price: USD 136.84. Proclear Toric is listed higher than Ultra for Astigmatism in this catalog. Price is one factor, but it should not override prescription fit and comfort.
What the supplied records leave open
Neither record includes base curve, diameter, oxygen transmissibility, or a full power range. Those are standard fitting details your eye doctor will use. The records also do not include care instructions, so follow the cleaning and storage routine your eye care professional gives you rather than improvising from a product page.
If you are choosing between these two monthly toric lenses, the honest takeaway is that they represent two different material approaches—higher-water samfilcon A with a digital-device design focus, and lower-water omafilcon B with a moisture-attracting technology and a tint. The right one for you depends on your prescription, your comfort history, and your eye doctor's assessment, not on which page lists more features.



